Are Electric Vehicles Truly Green? A Comparative Analysis of Traditional Combustion Engine Cars

Credit By: The D.U.Quark

The shift towards electric vehicles (EVs) has gained significant momentum as the automotive industry pledges billions to develop environmentally friendly electric options. While EVs promise to reduce tailpipe emissions, it’s essential to consider their environmental footprint throughout their entire lifecycle, from production to disposal. This article explores the ecological aspects of EVs, delving into their manufacturing process battery components and comparing them to traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) cars powered by petrol or diesel.

Manufacturing and Environmental Impact of EVs

The life cycle emissions of a product, such as an electric car, encompass everything from raw material extraction to battery production, vehicle manufacturing, usage, and disposal. One primary environmental concern lies in the extraction, refinement, transportation, and production of lithium-ion batteries used in EVs, which require extensive energy and contribute to emissions. Consequently, the production phase of battery electric cars tends to have higher emissions than their ICE counterparts.

Although the manufacturing process for ICE cars has a relatively lower carbon footprint, it still leaves a significant environmental footprint.

The Shift towards Carbon Neutrality

Car manufacturers are taking substantial steps to reduce their carbon footprint. Companies like Volkswagen, Toyota, Hyundai, Mercedes-Benz, and General Motors have pledged to achieve carbon neutrality in their operations. This includes carbon-neutral vehicles, manufacturing processes, and supply chains.

In contrast, Swedish company Polestar aims to create a net-zero car by 2030, striving to eliminate carbon emissions from raw material extraction to end-of-life handling.

Comparing Lifetime Emissions: EVs vs. ICE Cars

Although a notable carbon gap exists when an electric car is first sold, it narrows significantly over its lifetime. ICE cars continue to emit CO2 throughout their operational phase, while EVs are emissions-free, except for particles generated by tires and brakes.

Research by Transport & Environment (T&E), a European NGO, suggests that an average EU electric car has nearly three times lower carbon emissions than equivalent petrol or diesel cars, with this gap progressively widening. Even in scenarios where an EV with a battery produced in China is driven in Poland, it still emits 37 percent less CO2 than petrol.

An 83 percent reduction can be achieved when driving an electric car with a battery produced in Sweden and used in Sweden. The transition to cleaner energy sources in the EU’s electricity grid is expected to boost the environmental benefits of EVs further.

Addressing Battery Production Challenges

The cost of EVs remains higher than their ICE counterparts, primarily due to the raw materials used in battery production. As battery technology advances, alternatives to standard lithium-ion chemistry are emerging. Companies like BYD are actively reducing the use of rare minerals in their battery technology. The development of sodium-ion batteries and cobalt-free options reflects this shift towards sustainability.

Efforts to reduce the environmental impact of mining include reinvesting profits into local communities for education and training empowering those in developing countries.

Recycling and Sustainable Batteries

Recycling and reusing batteries are essential in reducing life cycle emissions from electric cars. The European Commission’s proposed regulation on batteries aims to foster ethical mining practices and promote recycling raw materials, aligning with the concept of a circular economy.

Upon reaching the end of their operational lives in EVs, batteries can be repurposed for a “second life” as electricity grid storage, further decreasing the overall carbon footprint of battery production.

A Greener Road Ahead with EVs

Despite the ecological challenges along their life cycle, EVs are poised to emerge as a significantly greener transportation option than traditional ICE cars. The continuous development of battery technology and manufacturing techniques will contribute to extended battery lifetimes, enhancing the overall sustainability of electric vehicles. While substantial challenges persist, it’s essential to recognize that the environmental impact of oil extraction for fuel is far more significant, reaffirming the ecological benefits of EVs.

Follow ARP Media for more informative blogs.

Contact us for an Advertisement